2022 Best Sellers

Bitch, please!  If you MIGHT believe we’re not alone in the universe… If you MIGHT have to explain the unexplainable… If you MIGHT not have the rig...

FINALLY!  This best-selling pin features the two words every character wants to be in a horror movie: FINAL GIRL. Set against a blood red glittery ...

Your pin collection is about to PEAK. This fan-favorite pin features artwork of a cherry pie slice and a cup of coffee that’s DAMN FINE. Get yours ...

I’ve seen the future and it GLOWS. The Future Ghost enamel pin was one of Creepy Co.'s very first products, emerging from the shadows back in 2015....

Make Halloween stick!  Our enamel Chompers pin makes a fang-tastic accent to any wardrobe. It even glows in the dark! Pin this to your lapel, jacke...

It sparkles! Perfect for display wherever and whenever! Marching under the same inclusive flag, monsters of all stripes get to celebrate their plac...

This mysterious blue crow caws in the night… This beautiful piece features the blue crow atop a jar of poison with a colorful stained glass window ...

One sip of this elixir will fix you right up! This classy yet morbid "poison" pin has just the right touch of macabre messaging. A clamorous chain ...

Extra! Extra! Scream all about it! We’re extremely proud of this beautiful pin celebrating the weird ‘n wonderful Weekly World News. A shine-shifti...

Some gals have all the luck! Whether bathing in the moonlight or going for a dip in the abandoned pool, this spooky pin-up girl never forgets her g...

A face only a mother could love. Toxie can now go wherever he’s needed! This glow-in-the-dark toxic teal enamel pin needs to be added to your colle...

Here lies the misanthrope, lying as they lived: shunning the company of the pre-deceased. Stoic as a statue, this pin can be used to clearly label ...

Don't breathe, you're dead. The infamously wronged groundskeeper pin has returned and he is out for blood. Grab this fiery hot piece of Creepy Co....

Whaaat's happening? So if you could snag this classic piece of Creepy Co. flair, that would be greeeat. Thanks a bunch. Artwork by Kellie Taylor ...

Sometimes it's nice to just warn people right away so they're prepared. This is the perfect pin (in the light or dark) to label your current condi...

Too HAUNT to handle!  Hit the lights in any room --haunted or not!-- and get an instant glow-up, thanks to this glow in the dark pin that features ...

Hear that cackling in the night sky? Own a part of Halloween history with this vintage reproduction of the Beistle® Witch and Moon artwork. Bring ...

If you were a member of the Monster Fan Club featured in 1970's horror comics you might recognize this beast! Life-size cutouts of the Moon Monste...

"Let the Good Times Roll!" Life is short, so live it up! Let this pin be your reminder to stare death squarely in the face, and vow to have a good...

Like a breath of fresh scare. This spine-chilling piece of jewelry is a sight to behold with a bold, monochromatic design highlighted by bright, go...